or are we having delusions of grandeur
Shit Punk Says
Oceans of Wisdom
22,259
matching drops
#1682654
2026-11-17 16:50
do you think there is some massive pent up demand right now to fund scientific research that I am leaving on the table with my "conservative" approach
So, why is the secondary market more important than the primary market when looking at a card to fund scientific resesarch, for instance?
there is not a single open edition I am am aware of ex, I dunno xcopy, that has performed in the secondary market
no it is a horrible idea
no it is a horrible idea
Ha ha ha... no, I didn't. But it might be time when we're looking at new ideas, like funding scientific research, to go back to that open/timed edition format.
WHO WANTS TO GUESS WHAT HAPPENED NEXT?!
WE HAD SO MUCH DEMAND
edition sizes soared
because they got SUPER POPULAR
SZN2 almost killed The Memes
someone missed SZN2
It would still be limited by the 24-hour time frame, but if @[ack] drops a Meme card, and it sells 5k, why not? Or more importantly, if someone wants to fund scientific research through a Meme card, doesn't having it capped limit the effectiveness of the Meme card as a funding source?
well I think there is a difference between +50 to someone and -50 to someone else, then it is fine. if it is to the same person, it is different
hmm, i take a look tomorrow, but just for case, isnt it that you "spend" it? rep proxy should be "credit" what you can spend. so if he gives you 100 credit, you do +50 and -50 you are out of credit and he needs to credit you more.
Dont rememeber reason why it was done that way, but pretty sure "because of gaming" or smth like this
sure, who decides the edition size
is there like A REASON why it's a bad idea whe're not coming up with
umm...
ooooooh... yes, let's get to the idea of opening up the Meme card editions so there is no cap!
this is a very complicated question that I have struggled with - I am not yet happy with any answer I have come up with
2) Gpebbles would like to run a superbowl commercial - to fund the commercial, he would like an open edition meme card that could raise a LOT of money, theoretically
oh yeah this seems wrong @[GelatoGenesis] / @[simo] can you take a look
1) ruskin proxied me a bunch of rep. i used it on memes nominee and now i can't remove it or do anything else with it
no i did not see. explain further
Punk did you see our desperate pleas for your attention earlier about two matters? 1) proxy rep should be like reg rep 2) some meme cards could be open edition if for cause?
i think gray just needs a bit of myers briggs finetuning
and on E v I, I mean, I am not quiet online and I am not quiet offline
I dunno, I think I am a pretty strong P end to end
i wonder if Punk presents a little different than the underlying homie
dude do you know how many times I have been yelled at online For NOt BuYING ThE RIGHT NfT?!
Imagine giving back to the community, help create a movement in community, bring everyone together in the community and get mad about that LOOOOL is doesn't make sense.đđ
decent! but I am an ENTP and an extremely strong P, not at all a J
**1. Communication style & tone:**
punk6529 delivers wisdom in bite-sized, sardonic nuggetsâthink streetwise cryptographer meets âseen-it-allâ late-night cabbie. Their messages toggle between clipped (often just a sentence or two) and dryly humorous, with a knack for understated observations. Earnestness peeks through the cynicism, but the vibe is resolutely rational, with a splash of meme-age and an allergic reaction to hand-holding. Calls it like they see it, spares you the small talk.
**2. Key interests & recurring topics:**
punk6529 is drawn to everything decentralized, especially the pipes and wiringâprotocols, governance, NFTs, tokens, incentives, and the tragedies/comedies of crowds. Real-world experience and finance crop up, as do references to tech, gamification, and quality control. When it comes to memes, theyâre both a participant and a sardonic commentator.
**3. Myers-Briggs guess:**
**INTJ**
- **I**: Leans inwardâsuccinct, reflective, not much emotional overshare.
- **N**: Spots abstract patterns, talks big-picture and system design.
- **T**: Ruthlessly logical, sometimes detached (âphysics does not careâ).
- **J**: Prefers order, structure, and end-statesâwants things organized, repeatable, and readable.
**4. The Gray summary:**
Punk6529 is basically the barstool Gandalf of crypto and chaosâa hard-boiled operator with one foot in the spreadsheets and the other on the NFT dance floor. If you want a pep talk, look elsewhere; but if you need someone to break down the odds with dry wit, heâs your guy. Donât expect him to buy the next round, though; heâs already calculating the utility curve of tipping the bartender.
all of this "pick me" cope. literally that is all it is.
As has been discussed in various places, everyone coming out with claws to tear down Bats is crazy... we all need to work together to build this space, not spend time and energy tearing it down.
nice
6529 Shillandia Auction: Liberty Enlightening The World by @[Beholdingeye]
yup yup
fwiw I agree
I think it absolutely made sense as a variation on the Art Blocks model and to encourage artists who were curated into the project to stick around and drop other work AND it was a huge reach amplification for those artists who wanted to use it
... but now it is complicating the contract model
num num
Todayâs meal was wagyu steak đ at a Brazilian Japanese kitchen/bar
of course they will continue - they are now permanently part of ETH
Totally understandable ser. MemeLab was something special and will always have its own place, there are some truly amazing cards and a lot of personal favorites in there.
Just to confirm, all the works that were already minted will continue to live on in the same contract, right?
i agree - we have a lot of complexity to work through
I support it. Any simplification that does not remove key functionality and simplifies the system is, in my opinion, a good thing in our case. In this case, I think it is clear that it did not bring us anything significant and only complicated the system.
yeah but I think cause and effect might be mixed. I am not sure it ever had a super winning concept in substance
Also, all of this affects interest in Meme Lab. Most people just scroll past it. Maybe if it were packaged in a more appropriate wayâmatching the complexity and overall feelâso it aligned more with the core collectionâs value, it could have been a turning point. But yeah, in its current state, it clearly doesnât catch the eye or create a strong desire to add, support, or engage with it.
contracts are going to work forever. what I mean is "no new mints"
anyone remeber what contract the memelabs are on? @[punk6529] i wonder samething as rakesh we can still buy and sell memelab cards they are just going to be capped right? what rights did memelabs have in the protocol?
I think we should formally sunset Memes Lab for the following reason:
- I think the topic can now be solved more generally -> the idea of minting special for meme card creators does not make a ton of sense in where we are going
- It is anyway not particularly being used
- I think it confuses the story at a protocol level. I want the protocol to be as protocol like as possible and it seems weird in the context of a network state - it is one thing to say we vote for block production for meme cards but the idea that if you get a meme card in, you get special protocol treatment for life is weird
- I think this is not a hugely hard decision but raising it for stakeholder discussion ;)
- cc @[6529er]
gm
yes it guides you to the optimal you
i feel like it actually optimizes the collective by rewarding the optimal you
yes
and it is just next level sir when you fully immerse yourself here.. i think you and bats have potential through this initiative to move us to next level.. meanwhile we do things like science and new type of mints.. i continue to believe the real alpha will be setting up shop here as it is not just about getting a meme card selected.. waves with tabs will be great for that and making this your hub imo
we are best at this by far!
There aren't many places in crypto art that have community voted drops and not many with the same momentum and continued interest. Just saying this because some of the closest comparisons often have a closed selection process where the criteria is either unclear or what's actually clear is they only pick artists that are popular on twitter, have the biggest sales stats etc. I've been in discords where that's all the collectors want too, they are just asking curators when will they get the next big artist to drop. I do feel this place is unique how many artists have been getting their work selected (through voting) and the drops are so well received. It's something to applaud. Many have failed to have the same reach.
wow
Feeling devilishly memetic today.. 
we need to be around in case @[BatSoupYum] loses his reading glasses and starts buying pokeman cards by mistake
we need to be around in case @[BatSoupYum] loses his reading glasses and starts buying pokeman cards by mistake
https://x.com/punk6529/status/2020584867994702198?s=20
please let us know @[simo] @[GelatoGenesis] @[prxt0] if not
I think we might have fixed the crashing/performance issue from Fri/Sat
ok speech over
and that is fine
they would trade off stability for agency
95% of people are not cut out for this I thikn
and that is fine
not everyone is cut out for this!
also get a vote about how this goes
but you know the counterparties (I dunno, in that case the Taliban I guess)
if you choose to do this, it is very admirable
just like nobody at gunpoint grabs librarians and auditors and sends them to Seal Team Six to jump out of helicopters