22,255 matching drops
#1681095 2026-11-17 07:55
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1628466 2026-11-05 19:18
Correct
Context from blake69 #1628449 2026-11-05 19:14
is not the right place for maybe’s stories 😂😂
punk6529 Follow The Repo #1628462 2026-11-05 19:17
Not sure. I think for next phase noon nft ppl the shield may be better. Will think about it
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1628448 2026-11-05 19:14
Could be fun! And let's us uncover more bugs
Context from Melted #1628426 2026-11-05 19:10
I have sooooooo many computers im not using should I be running more than one node?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1628404 2026-11-05 19:07
Glad to hear. My goal is one day for us to have the most validators on the planet!
Context from Ebrahim_Elmi #1627696 2026-11-05 17:40
dear Punk I just wanted to say installing the validator was so easy like a piece of cake and the hole introduction about errors or problems was so complete . you thought about every details . sometimes I think you are an AI brain . because you know everything :grinning:
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627652 2026-11-05 17:29
we will look at this too
Context from david #1627639 2026-11-05 17:27
I ususally login to the laptop with keys from my phone. the validator setup doesn't seem to like that workflow
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627589 2026-11-05 17:07
Giving you the air support while you fight the ground war.
Context from maybe #1627585 2026-11-05 17:06
here you are being all inspirational while i'm trying to meet my quotas
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627587 2026-11-05 17:06
This will be our greatest challenge. I can't promise we can engineer around it so you can connect via Tor but we will try. Wait until tomorrow's, we try again and then we probably will need to try again after that after we learn what works (or more likely, what doesnt)
Context from mingt #1627579 2026-11-05 17:04
yes
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627578 2026-11-05 17:03
And you ask yourself, why does this matter? Why this obsession? Why worrying about these edge cases? And the answer to this is that there is almost nothing in this world that can give you the assurance that if you make a digital commitment, it will be executed the way you made it, regardless of what else may happen in the world. I believe the only inventions humanity has ever made that have succeeded in this proposition are Bitcoin and Ethereum. This is the only purpose of crypto. This is the only time it matters. It is actually worse at everything else than doing it in a centralized manner. And if you simply focus on this one benefit and think obsessively about all the ways it can work, eventually you create something that is extraordinarily rare in the world, and then valuable because people can say, I don't have to worry about this. I trust you as a platform. You don't have to worry that an Ethereum NFT is going to go away, someone's going to change policy, and it disappears. And therefore it has infinitely more value than if it was a badge on Amazon.com. So this is why I keep saying this is our only real goal. We succeed in this, all the rest will come along.
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627575 2026-11-05 17:03
Yes
Context from mingt #1627573 2026-11-05 17:03
Do I just need to wait for the new version's feature updates?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627567 2026-11-05 17:01
Take a rest and we try tomorrow
Context from punk6529bot #1627559 2026-11-05 16:58
It's the same bridges line as before: the validator still finds it at every start and stops. Two ways out: 1. Now: quit the app (Cmd-Q). In Finder press Cmd-Shift-G, paste ~/Library/Application Support/6529-validator and press Return. Open config.toml in TextEdit, find the part from bridges = [ to the next ] (in the [tor] section), replace all of it with bridges = [] and save. Open the app again. 2. Or sleep on it, as punk6529 said: rc.8 tomorrow is meant to skip a bad line like that and offer to remove it.
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627566 2026-11-05 17:00
Then what about two physical machines, but in the same building? Well, you pick up the benefit that something might happen physically to one machine, or even possibly a bug or a virus in one machine but not the other. What about two physical machines in the same building, but on a different network? A little bit more. What about two physical machines, but not in the same building? A little bit more. What about two physical machines, but not in the same geography? A little bit more. What about two physical machines, but not in the same legal and regulatory system? A little bit more. What about two physical machines, but with different operating systems and not in the same geography? A little bit more. You can see there is no bright line. It is every single step you take, and our goal is to take as many steps in as many directions as possible, buys you incremental more likelihood that every 12 seconds we will validate forever and ever. This is what we're playing for.
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627556 2026-11-05 16:57
Then what about two virtual machines on one physical? That helps a bit. You could imagine you click a fake Minister of Valuation meeting in one but not in the other
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627551 2026-11-05 16:56
If we want "family pack" we just let it validate for up to X people
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627547 2026-11-05 16:55
So on one machine (virtual) the validator will only run once
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627546 2026-11-05 16:55
You might as well let your wife also use your sum from the one Excel
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627543 2026-11-05 16:54
Does "opening excel twice in windows" do anything or are you LARPing?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627539 2026-11-05 16:54
What if your PC crashed, your house flooded, the gestapo confiscate your computer
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627532 2026-11-05 16:53
What if someone put a virus on your windows account to corrupt excel results?
Context from maybe #1627526 2026-11-05 16:52
god in my crazy conception of this, one excel could crash on the same machine while the other continues
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627527 2026-11-05 16:52
"What do we need to do to be able to be as confident as possible that whatever happens that we agree on what Excel sums a set of numbers to
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627517 2026-11-05 16:50
BTW this is exactly the right mental model for the validators
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627515 2026-11-05 16:49
Assume the exercise is "we need to sum a set of numbers", "we don't want anyone in charge", 'we want the summing to work regardless if any persons Excel crashes, goes offline, has a malicious bug etc" In that world what does "multiple copies of Excel mean"
Context from punk6529 #1627504 2026-11-05 16:47
Explain it as if it was Excel
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627504 2026-11-05 16:47
Explain it as if it was Excel
Context from maybe #1627500 2026-11-05 16:46
on my hard drive
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627502 2026-11-05 16:46
I suspect as a sidequest we will learn how good the Great Firewall of China is. Don't know what the outcome will be
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627498 2026-11-05 16:45
Ok and when you have multiple of them, where are they
Context from maybe #1627491 2026-11-05 16:44
this may be the problem, let me think about that.... like a unit of software that does stuff that requires a unique signature?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1627495 2026-11-05 16:45
Tomorrow I will be doing an information session on progressively more exotic Tor measures and the private and national firewalls that will battle them. There is no guarantee that Tor works every day against any firewall. It is a constant battle, will never end
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627486 2026-11-05 16:43
Go to bed and get your beauty sleep! Release candidate 8 will be tomorrow when we try again
Context from lake #1627481 2026-11-05 16:42
About how long will the wait be? Can I go to sleep in the meantime?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627482 2026-11-05 16:42
What is "a node" in your mental model?
Context from maybe #1627471 2026-11-05 16:40
the concept i had in my head for how this would work was that each node would be a bit of a walled garden that would point to the same local eth node or rpc...
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627477 2026-11-05 16:41
If Tor is blocked on your network and you want to connect with Tor, you can try to configure some annoying things to hide Tor from your network operator, or run without Tor, or wait for tomorrow's and subsequent releases that try to do the annoying things for you.
Context from maybe #1627459 2026-11-05 16:37
if a person is committed to connecting through tor, they should wait, correct
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627467 2026-11-05 16:39
I don't think I said that tbh. Also there is a difference between physical and virtual machines. Also the family case is real, we could have a limited number allowed etc. As I said, I have not fully thought it through yet!
Context from gpebbles #1627393 2026-11-05 16:16
fyi @[punk6529] and @[punk6529bot] previous guidance was one computer can run validators for multiple accounts.. but either way all good and would appreciate heads up when you do know so i can be properly set up for the other account and a smaller family account
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627462 2026-11-05 16:37
Exactly. I don't want all of you to say "cool, i will just point my signature at the validator that punk6529 runs. Of course you can run virtual machines etc but the general theory is we want (and are willing to pay validator awards for as many diverse machines as possible)
Context from gpebbles #1627415 2026-11-05 16:23
@[maybe] just right here.. punk saying not sure yet on it for concentration dynamics.. which i do not know exactly what they are.. like i am sure it is not about me having two accounts on one machine but more so if you start running all the acccounts on your one machine.. however i still think someone could then just have another machine plugged in right next to it if they were running tons of accoutns so the barrier i am not sure if large to prevent that.. but above my paygrade just guesstimating
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627377 2026-11-05 16:13
Good comments
Context from eddie #1627307 2026-11-05 15:57
if Validate is still for today, it's still confusing since the text above says next validation is tmrw. If today is "practice" validation since it's already reached consensus, id explain this differently. Also, for the 8 steps, i'd add a notethat it's normal to take 30+ mins
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627373 2026-11-05 16:13
This is a good idea
Context from punk6529bot #1627317 2026-11-05 15:59
Good idea, noted: one place to see all your validators and move their shares around.
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627372 2026-11-05 16:12
Not sure about this. It creates some concentration dynamics. No commitment to this yet. Need to think about ut
Context from gpebbles #1627332 2026-11-05 16:02
sounds good.. it is fair to assume that by the time we hit go time we will be able to run multiple accounts on same computer?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1627201 2026-11-05 15:38
Great Day 1 start and day not even over!!!
Context from punk6529bot #1627059 2026-11-05 15:04
As of 14:50 UTC, 45 keys from 41 accounts are authorized for tomorrow's day (Fri 6 Nov), 40 of those accounts outside 6529. Today only 6529's own keys sign, because a new authorization counts from the next day. Tonight is the first day with outside validators.
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1626909 2026-11-05 14:39
hey the Minister is about to appear - I wonder if he knows how to run his validator yet?!
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1626905 2026-11-05 14:38
online at validator page
Context from lake #1626877 2026-11-05 14:32
Is there a tutorial?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1626898 2026-11-05 14:37
yup good rc8 pls
Context from punk6529bot #1626890 2026-11-05 14:36
On it. Every step that can take a while is being reviewed for the next release, so each one shows movement while it works: counts that move block by block rather than in thousands, what it's doing right now, and no time left until there's a real rate. A restart will also say it restarted and why, rather than looking like a fresh setup.
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1626895 2026-11-05 14:37
nothing bad happens
Context from web3vee #1626886 2026-11-05 14:34
What if my internet breaks ?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1626861 2026-11-05 14:30
yeah we need to show more continuous feedback
Context from Vantekai #1626844 2026-11-05 14:28
Typically after I posted it changed to 1000 and then like someone above said chugs along bit faster after that![Seize](https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/drops/217bbfe8-fa84-48b1-a633-6b910d5a5f6c/image.png)
punk6529 Ministry of Validation #1626836 2026-11-05 14:26
anyway so pumped, tonight for the first time we will have true decentralized consensus on TDH
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1626834 2026-11-05 14:26
@[punk6529bot] do a review of all "in progress indicators" to make sure we are showing progress (even if slow) when it is happening so people don't worry
Context from Vantekai #1626787 2026-11-05 14:17
Ive been here for a while (10 mins) ![Seize](https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/drops/aa893138-ff87-48ec-8fd0-10c046bdbd81/image.png) Should it check any of those 11345 and move on from stage 5 of 8 ?
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1626771 2026-11-05 14:09
i like!
Context from Mahan #1626770 2026-11-05 14:09
Maybe can be the Minister of Validations, and I'll be the Minister of TDH Sponsorships
punk6529 Ministry of Validation Reply #1626763 2026-11-05 14:08
![Seize](https://d3lqz0a4bldqgf.cloudfront.net/drops/f027cba6-2f2f-40c9-a8d0-992baa9a6951/image.png)wtf lol
Context from punk6529 #1626758 2026-11-05 14:07
yes